·Hamilton Investment Properties

By Sandy MacKay·Founder & REALTOR®, Found Spaces Realty Group

Ontario Real Estate Investment Gets Cheaper Per Door in Hamilton. A Fourplex Asks $250,000 a Unit

For ontario real estate investment, Hamilton has a pattern worth knowing. Bigger buildings cost less for each unit. A Hamilton fourplex asks a median of $999…

Ontario Real Estate Investment Gets Cheaper Per Door in Hamilton. A Fourplex Asks $250,000 a Unit

For ontario real estate investment, Hamilton has a pattern worth knowing. Bigger buildings cost less for each unit. A Hamilton fourplex asks a median of $999,999, which is $250,000 per unit, according to our Hamilton duplex, triplex and fourplex report.

An up and down duplex asks $374,950 per unit in the same report. That is $124,950 more for each unit than in a fourplex. These are asking prices from 12 months of listings, not final sale prices. They still show you where the value sits before you start looking.

Written by Sandy MacKay, who leads Found Spaces Realty Group in Burlington, Hamilton and Niagara.

Our Ontario guide covers the basics. This post goes one level down. It shows what each size of Hamilton building costs per unit, what the bank asks you to put down, and how much of the rent the bank will count as your income. A cheap price per unit is a good start. It only becomes a good buy once you can afford the down payment and the rents hold up.

The price per unit in Hamilton, building by building

Investors call each unit a "door." So "price per door" means the building's price split evenly across its units. It's the fastest way to compare a duplex to a fourplex.

These are the median asking prices from our Hamilton multiplex report:

  • Duplex, side by side: $689,900, or $344,950 per unit
  • Duplex, up and down: $749,900, or $374,950 per unit
  • Triplex: $799,900, or $266,633 per unit, from 67 listings in 12 months
  • Fourplex: $999,999, or $250,000 per unit, from 26 listings in 12 months

Look at the jump from an up and down duplex to a triplex. The triplex asks $50,000 more ($799,900 minus $749,900). For that $50,000 you get a whole third unit with its own rent. That gap is the most interesting number on the page, because a third unit in Hamilton earns rent every single month, and $50,000 is a small price for a whole stream of rent if the unit is legal and the tenant pays.

The fourplex asks $250,099 more than the up and down duplex. That buys two more units. It's the lowest price per door on the list.

There's a catch. The fourplex count is small, with just 26 listings in 12 months. You won't have many to choose from. And a median is the middle listing, so half the fourplexes asked more and half asked less.

What the bank lets you put down, and how much rent it counts

This is where the cheap price per door starts to cost you. The rules change once a building has three or four units.

If you live in one unit and rent out the others, that's called house hacking. The rent from the other units helps pay your mortgage. It works with two, three or four units, and the federal mortgage insurer, CMHC, sets the rules on how much you need down.

Two units (a duplex or a house with one legal second unit): you can put down the same as for a regular house. That's 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the part above that. The bank can count up to 100% of the expected rent from the other unit toward what it will lend you.

Three or four units: you need at least 10% down. The bank counts only up to 50% of the rent (or the rent after costs).

Using the median asking prices as an example:

  • Up and down duplex at $749,900: 5% of $500,000 is $25,000, plus 10% of the other $249,900, which is $24,990. That's $49,990 down.
  • Triplex at $799,900: 10% is $79,990 down.
  • Fourplex at $999,999: 10% is about $100,000 down.

So the triplex asks $50,000 more than the duplex, but the down payment goes up by $30,000. And the bank counts only half the rent instead of all of it. A lot of buyers see the lower price per door and skip right past that second part, which is why some of them find out late that the bank won't lend them as much as they hoped, even though the building has more rent coming in.

We wrote a full post on whether a first-time buyer can do this with a triplex or fourplex. The short version is yes, with 10% down and a bank that will lend you enough.

A tale of two buyers

Picture two friends, each with about $110,000 saved, shopping Hamilton at the same time. These numbers are round and made up, only to show the idea. One falls for a fourplex because the price per door is the lowest she's seen. She puts close to $100,000 down and moves in with about $10,000 left over, and in the first winter a furnace and a roof leak eat all of it. The other buys an up and down duplex with about $50,000 down and keeps $60,000 in the bank. His price per door was higher, but he slept fine when his water heater quit. Both bought good buildings. Only one of them left room for the things that break.

The takeaway: the lowest price per door only wins if you still have cash left after you buy. Plan for the down payment, the closing costs and a repair fund, then see which building size fits.

What October 2026 says about buying in Hamilton right now

The multiplex figures are asking prices. For what Hamilton homes are selling for, our Hamilton market report for October 2026 shows:

  • 361 home sales, up 4% from a year earlier
  • An average freehold sale price of $738,207, down 1% from a year earlier
  • 40 days on market on average
  • 1,003 new listings
  • 2,477 homes for sale

These numbers cover all houses, semis and townhouses, not only rentals. They still tell you the mood of the market.

Divide 2,477 homes for sale by 361 sales and you get close to seven months' worth of homes on the market. Homes took 40 days to sell on average. That means buyers have time to look, ask questions and check the rents before they sign. In a rushed market, people skip those checks. In October 2026 Hamilton, nobody needed to.

One comparison is worth making, carefully. The median up and down duplex asks $749,900. The average freehold home sold for $738,207 in October. The gap is $11,693. One number is an asking price and the other is a sale price, so this is a rough comparison. It does suggest that in Hamilton, a home with a second rental unit can cost not much more than a regular house.

Check that the units are legal and the rents are real

A lot of Hamilton's duplexes and triplexes are older houses that someone split into units years ago. Some were done with permits. Some were not.

A unit without proper permits can be a problem. The bank may not count its rent. Your insurance may not cover it. You may have to pay to bring it up to code. So before you make an offer, check the City of Hamilton's building and zoning records, and ask the seller for any permits and inspection papers they have.

Rents need the same care. A listing might say a unit "could rent for" a certain amount. That's a guess.

One thing I ask for on every income property: copies of the signed leases, in writing, before we talk price. The rent on a listing sheet is only a claim until there's a signed lease behind it.

Also know what you can and can't change. In Ontario, you can't raise a sitting tenant's rent to whatever the market pays. For most older units (first rented before November 15, 2018), rent increases follow a yearly limit set by the province. So if a triplex has long-term tenants paying low rent, those rents will likely stay low for a while. That can still be a fine building. You just need to price it on the rent it has today.

Run the numbers before the price wins you over

Once you know the rents are real and the units are legal, do the math on what's left each month. Rent comes in. Out goes the mortgage, property tax, insurance, repairs, any utilities you pay and a bit set aside for empty months between tenants.

We lay out how we check a deal on our page on how we run the numbers on an income property. It shows what share of the rent we set aside for costs, and it gives you a prompt you can paste into an AI assistant to check a listing yourself.

A few mistakes we see often:

  • Using the rent the listing hopes for instead of the rent on the leases.
  • Forgetting that in a triplex or fourplex, the bank counts only half the rent.
  • Leaving no repair money after closing.
  • Comparing buildings on full price instead of price per door.

If you'd like to see what's for sale and how we look at Hamilton income buildings, our Hamilton investment properties page is a good place to start. It covers Ancaster, Dundas, Stoney Creek, Waterdown, Binbrook and Flamborough as well as the lower and upper city.

Which size do I like? For most first buyers, I lean toward a triplex. You get the lower price per door and a third rent. The down payment is still within reach for a lot of people who've saved hard. Some will disagree and say a duplex is safer because the bank counts all the rent. They have a point. But that $50,000 gap for a whole extra unit is hard to ignore.

Questions people ask

Do I have to live in the building to put only 5% or 10% down?

Yes. The low down payments are for buyers who live in one of the units. If the building is only a rental and you live somewhere else, banks usually ask for at least 20% down. That's a big jump, so decide early whether you'll move in.

Does a house with a legal second and third unit count as a triplex?

Yes. The bank counts units, so a house with your unit plus two legal rental units is treated as three units. The same 10% down rule and the 50% rent rule apply. A house with only one extra unit is treated as two units.

Are side by side duplexes easy to find in Hamilton?

Not very. Our report counted 22 side by side duplex listings in 12 months, compared with 112 up and down duplexes. If you want a side by side, set up alerts and expect to wait. When one comes up, be ready to look fast.

Send us the building you're weighing

Tell us which Hamilton listing you're looking at, or which size of building you think fits your savings. We'll go over the rents, the price per door and the down payment with you on a call. Reach our team here.